|
| Song | Artist | Arranger | Soloist | Duetist |
| Aside | The Weakerthans | Drew | ||
| A Favor House Atlantic | Coheed and Cambria | Drew Dickens | Kristen | |
| Here (in Your Arms) | Hellogoodbye | Vinay Baliga | Hillary | |
| Move Along | The All-American Rejects | Drew Dickens | Justin | Stephen |
| Mr. Brightside | The Killers | Drew Dickens | Vinay | |
| My Oh My | Aqua | Aaron McClannon | Hillary/Tate | |
| Offbeat of Avenues | Manhattan Transfer | Kristen Meinhold | Everyone | |
| Perfect | Simple Plan | Heather Onorati | Justin | |
| Sweet Dreams of Sunglasses | Eurythmics/Corey Heart | Justin Bradshaw | Drew/Carole | Pam |
| Such Great Heights | The Postal Service | Heather Nofziger | Curtis/Hillary | |
| Superman | REM | Kit | Pam/Daniel | |
| Swing, Swing | The All-American Rejects | Drew Dickens | Justin | |
| Thanks Fr The Mmrs | Fall Out Boy | Drew Dickens | Vinay | Drew/Justin |
| Unwritten | Natasha Bedingfield | Hillary Wagstaff | Kristen | Hillary |
| You Are the One | Shiny Toy Gun | Drew Dickens | Drew | Kristen |
| Your Star | Evanescence | Drew Dickens | Meredith | Hillary |
| Working On: | ||||
| Beautiful Day | U2 | Elene Dahners | Vinay | |
| Retired: | ||||
| Eden | Sarah Brightman | Alan Painter | Sage | |
| Don't Think of Me | Dido | Justin Bradshaw | Sage | |
| King of the Road | Roger Miller | Rayanna Aldridge | Mary | |
| Laughing Out Loud | The Wallflowers | Heather Onorati | Justin | Heather |
| Pachabel's Hook | Blues Traveler | Zack Moser | Heather | |
| St. Teresa | Joan Osborne | Kit | Heather | |
| Total Eclipse of the Heart | Bonnie Tyler | Zack Moser | Kristen | Heather |
| Wake Me Up When September Ends | Green Day | Elene Dahners | Curtis |